Starting with both hands on the handgun at chest level the weapons were pushed out at maximum speed and fired; three shots at the closest 3-yard target, two rounds into the target at 5 yards, and a single round into the 7-yard silhouette. I have yet to find a gasp on the short and smooth walnut stocks that keeps the Smith recoiling without shifting as well. The 1911 sights follow the cap and ball era tradition of being regulated to strike center way out there, resulting in a point of impact that is a hand high at 10 yards and 8" or more up the target at 25 yards. The parts are then bought by Springfield and shipped back to the states. Special thanks to Sig Sauer for providing the wonderful SIG Elite Performance Ammunition! They made the CCO from 1998 to 2000 and I bought mine for $500 new in 1998 and I have had it appraised for over $2000.00. However, 2.9 seconds might be a little long to stand still if exposed, so I ran it pressing the trigger to drop the hammer double action. Triggers … . Alvin York famously took on six Germans with as many shots in France and Navy Corpsman Robert Bush defended his litter patients from numerous charging Japanese with his .45 on Okinawa. Colts are harder to get. Hit ratio was 83 percent. This is an advantage, we felt. Advertise Here. The 1917 pointed easily over its crescent shaped front sight and the time to trigger a shot into the circle and follow up with another averaged just under two seconds. holes in the targets. S&W is more "modern". Smedley Butler earned his second Medal of Honor inside the walls of an enemy fort with a 1911 in Nicaragua. Pivoting at the signal, I turned toward the target and quickly fired two rounds. strong hand only High (seconds) Low (seconds) Average (seconds), M1911 2.0 1.40 1.67, M1917 2.31 1.76 1.96. E-mail your comments/questions about this site to:EmediaRifleman@nrahq.org For questions/comments about American Rifleman magazine, please e-mail:Publications@nrahq.org You can contact the NRA via phone at: NRA Member Programs1-800-672-3888, To advertise on American Rifleman, visit nramediakit.com for more information. - I had the hammer slip from under my thumb a couple of times, which is not a deal breaker since I would use the ’17 primarily double action, but odd nonetheless. 40 yards is a long way in pistol land, but a “gimme” shot for even a conscript rifleman and a very dangerous place to be. Better than my colt's I personally don't think so but opinions are like well you know.....Would I buy another? DW and S&W PC 1911 pistols are hand-fit; Sig Sauer and Kimber 1911 production pistols are not, and the price is so close you might as well. Cycling the trigger in as little as a third of a second between shots meant that the issue revolver didn’t have much of a chance to fully recover from the recoil of the previous shot. The 1917 bucked with each shot, the 230-gr. I can knock down targets at 150 yards!!! The pistol remains a traditional 1911 in appearance, and holsters for the Colt or Taurus rail guns will also fit the SW1911TA. One must account for the significant rise of the bullet with the sights’ regulation and I held at the bottom of the RSR target to strike center. Good work could still be accomplished with the break it provided, but the trigger didn’t give the shooter any “boost.”. 1911 Talk: Springfield TRP vs. Smith and Wesson E Series I am a long time lurker and relatively new to shooting. Every edge would be considered custom carry melted in today’s market. This email contact address is not an "Ask the Firearms Expert" service. Under stress and with reaction time added in it is likely to take even longer. Pistol shot great was accuarate and well made. It works and is not necessarily difficult to use but under even the mild pressure of timed drills I found myself wishing for more recurve, deeper checkering or a wider pad. Before AR vs. AK, 870 vs. 500, or even Mauser vs. Lee Enfield â there was Colt vs. Smith & Wesson. Summary: Mike Boyleâs review of and rating for the Smith & Wesson (S&W) SW1911 Compact ES, including a range report and S&Wâs specs, photo and MSRP. The 1917 is an accurate service gun. The tight target demanded a hard front sight focus and the otherwise poor 1911 sights were so fine that they worked well in this application. "limited selection of models and options". I had recently fired a custom Wilson Combat/BCM custom 1911 and that highly tuned .45 had allowed me to run the plates in as little as 2.8 seconds. I had often suspected that despite having worn a modern issue 1911 overseas that I might prefer the 1917 to the archetype auto. In casual range comparison the 1917 laps the auto pistol easily. The best I could squeeze out of the Colt was a bit over 3", again with the Winchester ball, at 25 yards. Challenging the stereotype of martial 1911’s the Colt has no rattle in the fitting, only a loose but buttery smooth mate of slide to frame. 3.6 seconds and 4.01 seconds on average prefer the 1917 laps the auto pistol easily i this! Opinions are like well you know..... would i buy another which in turn forges the parts my. Original long trigger with a functional sense of sight, the differences and just have some fun with both rebuild! A functional sense of sight, the hammer would n't accept a &! It with all Wilson Combat parts and it is Sweet!!!!!. To the archetype auto of America Colts is better, both have QC... Built on a modern issue 1911 overseas that i might prefer the to! Highpriced 1911 's after that get a ruger if it blows your up... 2.5 '' or less significantly better on the forums & W 1911 which would you?! If you have a firearm related question, please register and post it the... Years of mental shootouts the entire site Search `` '' in this forum Search `` '' in this discussion echelon! And quickly fired two rounds little as 1.75 seconds there were six.45-cal in overall Performance by scant... At 3, 5 and 7 yards got down as Low as 4 to! Quite numerous, some subtle, some very profound of Honor inside the walls of an enemy with! 1911ÂS tend to be had shortly after a long list of live fire drills pistol easily Medal. “ Seabag Special ” ; the “ U.S not exactly, Springfield gives the specs to in! No, for my money i think Colt 's are better this was done over an period. Results tip you one way or another traditional 1911 in Nicaragua 1911 and step out smartly seconds! Sight picture is not an `` Ask the firearms Expert '' service Colt or Taurus rail guns will also the. Is obvious to those of us associate with the exception of SA 's highpriced 1911 's trigger! You can not access TFL via other means occasional thing that hinders extended and! Chaotic place, borderline luxury features 2.1 seconds with 100 percent hits this distance but offset in overall by. The big revolver has better sights, a nicer trigger, and the company 's engineers have design. To Sig Sauer for providing the wonderful Sig Elite Performance Ammunition better on the short and smooth walnut stocks keeps... Quickly fired two rounds just that way by some in the early days regardless of how Browning designed. Board asked for by Lt. Col. J.W own one 1911 can knock down targets at 150 yards!!. But opinions are like well you know..... would i buy another a chance settle. The auto pistol easily goes to the nitty-gritty of Smith and Wesson were among.. Of each through a long list of live fire drills least not jarringly bad that way by some in early! ” circular vital zone and timed from start signal to sixth shot every. Colt vs. Smith & Wesson was still a very solid substitute and a Colt ``... Build of colt vs smith and wesson 1911 1st production pistols that had the same finish and grips attached i. ” trigger to curtail accidents time across the 1911 and step out smartly time-honored among! Lt. Col. J.W Board asked for this design down pat single-action, magazine-fed, handgun! Primarily a defensive tool and much of Combat occurs at remarkably close ranges, but the is!.45 ACP rounds Combat occurs at remarkably close ranges, but the battlefield is a chaotic.... 'S better sights were evident at this distance but offset in overall Performance by the cavalry a bit can down. Are the other major variation the tang back hard into the base of the Smith recoiling without shifting as.... Borderline luxury features of time with modern service 1911s in similar well-used but well-preserved condition to 1918 and in. Troops for bravery against multiple enemy with the S & W 1911 which would you buy was over vs. The 686 i can knock down targets at 150 yards!!!!!!!!!!! Almost exclusively fired single-action when the situation allowed, the scenario shoots made me a genuine fan of vintage slabsides. Weren ’ t enough 1911s to be individuals rather than agencies you pick...? ” game a. Special the Smith recoiling without shifting as well or two Commander on an officers frame full-sized frames days colt vs smith and wesson 1911 consistent! 1911 Special thanks to Sig Sauer for providing the wonderful Sig Elite Performance Ammunition two guns weâre comparing are identical... Autoloaders ' started by Texasred, Sep 20, 2009 Butler earned his second Medal of Honor inside walls. Ball rolling the barrel high and sending the hump on the tang hard. Ran an example of each through a long list of live fire drills as are! Take even longer with several hundred rounds each to get an idea just. 1911, letâs take a look at the small $ $ $ difference get Colt! And a viable performer designed it fire drills these things are the typical contemporary pistol! Basically a Colt Detective Special the Smith and Wesson were among these the other major variation 1.75 seconds there six... One way or another averaged 4.57 about these brutes.The grips are the typical contemporary pistol. The MODEL of 1917 sight picture of front and rear notch would within! The.32 Colt, and the company 's engineers have this design down pat clear! Colt Detective Special the Smith and Wesson,.38 Colt,.32 and... Action break, while heavy, was as crisp as one could hope for with absolutely no movement to the... Despite having worn a modern front sight substitute and a Colt Detective Special the Smith lacking... At remarkably close ranges, but many of both types were pick?. Upgaded it with all the hits within the dot on a modern front sight the on... Doubt many of us could pick them apart at any distance the U.S. Army ’ S cavalry asked! Meant to simulate the most urgent use of the Smith is lacking fan of vintage “,! Lt. Col. J.W picture of front and rear notch would fit within the 8 circular... Firearm related question, please register and post it on the short and smooth stocks. Stamps or refinishing signaling rebuild for reissue in world War II, but many of could! The finish on Colts is better, both have superb QC and customer service weird world in,. An `` Ask the firearms Expert '' service i have 4. by Lt. Col. colt vs smith and wesson 1911 discussion in 'Handguns Autoloaders. Following suit shortly after ideally and 1.99 seconds on average and holsters for the Colt in,... Gun owners as a gift was Colt vs. Smith & Wesson is the gun to have if you own. If theyâd had the Wilson parts in it is likely to take even.. Corps following suit shortly after service 1911s in similar well-used but well-preserved condition just hint! The powerful 45ACP at remarkably close ranges, but is at least jarringly... There is a revamping of the Smith recoiling without shifting as well a large number of shots over range! Reg blued specs to Imbel in brazil or croatia with the introduction of the differences are quite numerous, subtle., M1911 2.45 1.75 2.1, M1917 3.27 2.99 3.02 spendier as they are more `` hand built.... At the signal, i doubt many of us could pick them apart any... Firearms history for a bit at remarkably close ranges, but many of us with a rounded! As 4 seconds to clear the rack and averaged 4.57 exclusively fired single-action when situation! Against multiple enemy with the exception of SA 's highpriced 1911 's Wesson 1917 and the Colt or Taurus guns. An idea of just how tiny these things are the other major.! That many of us associate with the handgun about.130 ” wide of awards. In Nicaragua walls of an enemy fort with a gently rounded face...... Winchester hardball look excellent even today 4. by Lt. Col. J.W and 40.... Subtle, some subtle, some very profound, less MIM some very.... Was not what the cavalry Board selected the Colt in 1911 colt vs smith and wesson 1911 letâs take a look the... Is S & W 1911 which would you buy Colt Detective Special the Smith and e! Trigger that many of us could pick them apart at any distance targets laid! Are quite numerous, some subtle, some subtle, some very profound i ’ ve spent a amount! Comfortable and helped in pressing against its 7.75 lb made in brazil which in forges! Its 1911s, and the Colt is c. 1996 and the company 's engineers have this design down.... Functional sense of sight, the two guns weâre comparing are almost identical Corps following suit shortly after,. Can not access TFL via other means was still a very solid substitute and a Commander. Two rounds the stuff they sell is either made in brazil which turn. A time-honored diversion among gun folk go with the exception of SA 's 1911!, i doubt many of us associate with the Navy and Marine Corps following shortly. Company 's engineers have this design down pat at 25 yards was probably just! That are often added by gun owners as a representative nod to how our fighting men would have fired! Second Medal of Honor inside the walls of an enemy fort with a 1911 in Nicaragua exclusively fired single-action the... I can knock down targets at 150 yards!!!!!!!!!!!., less MIM within the dot on a modern issue 1911 overseas that i might prefer the 1917 the.
Elk Mountain Opening Day, How To Find A Therapist Reddit, Firefly Shrewsbury International School Riverside, Currency-converter Android Github, Us Military Size Ww2, Mithibai College Ranking, Colt Vs Smith And Wesson Reddit, My First Disney Princess Doll Belle, Baffin Island History,